Home > Political Science Questions Answers > Who among the following compares the organisations of civil society to a powerful system of 'Fortresses and earthworks' standing behind the state?
Who among the following compares the organisations of civil society to a powerful system of 'Fortresses and earthworks' standing behind the state?
A
McLellan
B
Bernstein
C
Lenin
D
Gramsci
Correct Answer:
D
Gramsci
This is unmistakably Antonio Gramsci, the Italian Marxist theorist. Gramsci wrote that the state was only an outer ditch, behind which there stood a powerful system of fortresses and earthworks, using this metaphor to describe how civil society reinforces and protects the state in Western capitalist societies.
- Context: Gramsci distinguished conditions in Russia, where the state was predominant while civil society was primitive and unformed, from the West, where there existed a proper relation between state and civil society
- Key Insight: When the state showed weakness, the institutions of civil society provided political reinforcement for the existing order
- Strategic Implication: Gramsci advocated a "war of position" instead of a direct "war of movement," requiring infiltration of the influential organizations that make up civil society
- Related Metaphor: Gramsci compared the massive structures of modern democracies and civil society to "trenches" and permanent fortifications in the war of position
- Why Others Are Wrong: McLellan is a Marx scholar/biographer, Bernstein is associated with revisionist socialism, and Lenin focused on the vanguard party and state seizure — none used this specific "fortresses and earthworks" formulation
